Open Access

Table 20

Calculated results of Pi, Ri, Qi and the ranking results.

Solutions Pi Ri Qi Ranking
1 24.6946 2.9062 21.7884 9
2 32.5447 12.3332 20.2115 8
3 23.1534 27.4276 –4.2742 2
4 24.3280 7.1865 17.1415 7
5 26.3738 24.8964 1.4774 3
6 21.2324 15.5024 5.7300 4
7 21.4616 14.3732 7.0884 5
8 22.8855 13.9420 8.9435 6
9 25.0548 37.9810 –12.9262 1